Top Tips

Adventures of a bridge professional

Adventures of a bridge professional.
Columns by Dutch National Team player Sjoert Brink. Check out the section Columns

Defending is cooperating (2) **
W/AllA K Q 7 6
 
 K J 10
Q 6 3
A K
5
windroos  
A 7 3
  
A K J 8 4
  
Q 10 8 2
  

WestNorthEastSouth
1doublepass1
pass4passpass
pass   

West leads the A, East contributing the 7 and South the 5. EW use classical signals, so high-low is a 'come on'-signal.
How should West defend?

Solution

From dummy it's clear that EW can make five tricks at best: AK, AQ (if East has the Q, the only important honour card West cannot see) and a diamond ruff.
West has to assume that South's 5 was not a singleton, for if it was, the contract cannot be defeated. By the way, South is bound to have at least one more diamond, since if the 5 was a singleton, East would have started with 10972. He wouldn't have encouraged with the 7 then, since he can see that South would ruff West's continuation of the K, leaving dummy's Q a master.

All right: East has three diamonds at most. In three cases he will play the 7 to the first trick:
1. He has started with the bare 7 or the 72 doubleton.
In that case West must continue the suit, giving East a ruff at the third trick. A is the setting trick (if East has the Q and South three or more hearts, EW will even collect two down tricks).
If, at that diamond layout, West were to play the A and another heart (or at once a low heart), he would give away the contract if South has the Q.
2. East has started with 1097.
In that case West must play the A and another heart (or at once a low heart), hoping that East has the Q.
If, at that diamond lay-out, West were to play the K, he would set up dummy's Q. If South has three small hearts, his third heart would disappear on that established Q.

What is West to choose?

The solution is that West doesn't have to choose at all. He asks his partner by playing the A (true, he has to hope that East can give a clear signal to this trick; if not — very unlikely — West will have to guess after all).
In case 1 East will play his lowest heart if he doesn't have the Q. West now plays the K and another diamond, East ruffing.
In case 2 East will play a high heart if he has the Q. West plays another heart and East will make the Q sooner or later (if declarer goes up with the K and later plays a diamond from South, West will of course go up with the K and play a heart to East's Q).

The latter is the case below: on the A East will convey a clear message by playing the 9: 'please, play another heart!'

W/AllA K Q 7 6
 
 K J 10
Q 6 3
A K
5
windroos10 3
A 7 3
Q 9 5 2
A K J 8 4
10 9 7
Q 10 8 2
6 5 4 3
 J 9 8 4 2
 
8 6 4
5 2
J 9 7

For connoisseurs: what if East is short in diamonds and has the Q?
- If he has started with the bare 7 and the Q, the best he can do is to play his lowest heart on the A. He ruffs the third diamond and even if South were to overruff, that wouldn't be a problem: East patiently waits for his Q to win the setting trick (this defence will only fail if West has eight diamonds and South exactly three hearts).
- if he has the 72 and the Q, East defends similarly, only losing if West has seven diamonds and South exactly three hearts.

And if East has started with 1097 and does not have the Q (so he signals low on the A), it's all futile: the contract cannot be defeated.

Like to try another puzzle in which the defenders have to cooperate? Then click Defence in bridge is cooperating (1) ***.