| W/All | ♠ | A K Q 7 6
| | | | ♥ | K J 10
| | ♦ | Q 6 3
| | ♣ | A K
| | ♠ | 5
|  | | | | ♥ | A 7 3
| | | | ♦ | A K J 8 4
| | | | ♣ | Q 10 8 2
| | |
| West | North | East | South |
|---|
| 1♦ | double | pass | 1♠ | | pass | 4♠ | pass | pass | | pass | | | |
West leads the ♦A, East contributing the ♦7 and South the ♦5. EW use classical signals, so high-low is a 'come on'-signal. How should West defend?
Solution From dummy it's clear that EW can make five tricks at best: ♦AK, ♥AQ (if East has the ♥Q, the only important honour card West cannot see) and a diamond ruff. West has to assume that South's ♦5 was not a singleton, for if it was, the contract cannot be defeated. By the way, South is bound to have at least one more diamond, since if the ♦5 was a singleton, East would have started with ♦10972. He wouldn't have encouraged with the ♦7 then, since he can see that South would ruff West's continuation of the ♦K, leaving dummy's ♦Q a master.
All right: East has three diamonds at most. In three cases he will play the ♦7 to the first trick: 1. He has started with the bare ♦7 or the ♦72 doubleton. In that case West must continue the suit, giving East a ruff at the third trick. ♥A is the setting trick (if East has the ♥Q and South three or more hearts, EW will even collect two down tricks). If, at that diamond layout, West were to play the ♥A and another heart (or at once a low heart), he would give away the contract if South has the ♥Q. 2. East has started with ♦1097. In that case West must play the ♥A and another heart (or at once a low heart), hoping that East has the ♥Q. If, at that diamond lay-out, West were to play the ♦K, he would set up dummy's ♦Q. If South has three small hearts, his third heart would disappear on that established ♦Q.
What is West to choose?
The solution is that West doesn't have to choose at all. He asks his partner by playing the ♥A (true, he has to hope that East can give a clear signal to this trick; if not — very unlikely — West will have to guess after all). In case 1 East will play his lowest heart if he doesn't have the ♥Q. West now plays the ♦K and another diamond, East ruffing. In case 2 East will play a high heart if he has the ♥Q. West plays another heart and East will make the ♥Q sooner or later (if declarer goes up with the ♥K and later plays a diamond from South, West will of course go up with the ♦K and play a heart to East's ♥Q).
The latter is the case below: on the ♥A East will convey a clear message by playing the ♥9: 'please, play another heart!' | W/All | ♠ | A K Q 7 6
| | | | ♥ | K J 10
| | ♦ | Q 6 3
| | ♣ | A K
| | ♠ | 5
|  | ♠ | 10 3
| | ♥ | A 7 3
| ♥ | Q 9 5 2
| | ♦ | A K J 8 4
| ♦ | 10 9 7
| | ♣ | Q 10 8 2
| ♣ | 6 5 4 3
| | | ♠ | J 9 8 4 2
| | | ♥ | 8 6 4
| | ♦ | 5 2
| | ♣ | J 9 7
|
For connoisseurs: what if East is short in diamonds and has the ♥Q? - If he has started with the bare ♦7 and the ♥Q, the best he can do is to play his lowest heart on the ♥A. He ruffs the third diamond and even if South were to overruff, that wouldn't be a problem: East patiently waits for his ♥Q to win the setting trick (this defence will only fail if West has eight diamonds and South exactly three hearts). - if he has the ♦72 and the ♥Q, East defends similarly, only losing if West has seven diamonds and South exactly three hearts.
And if East has started with ♦1097 and does not have the ♥Q (so he signals low on the ♥A), it's all futile: the contract cannot be defeated. Like to try another puzzle in which the defenders have to cooperate? Then click Defence in bridge is cooperating (1) ***. |